Five tools to stay safe from scammers

September 27, 2024   |   News & Updates

Doug Denlinger's photo

By Doug Denlinger

Doug Denlinger, RLP®, CKA® is the Managing Partner at LifeGuide Financial Advisors.

Scamming is rampant right now. In fact, according to the FTC, Americans lost more than $10 billion to fraud in 2023. 

And, unfortunately, once the money is gone, in most cases, it’s gone.

The reality is this: Anyone can become a scam victim—even you.

It’s not something that happens “out there somewhere” or to “someone else.” Scammers don’t discriminate; they are going after the smart, cautious, well-informed people you know—your family, friends, and co-workers…YOU!

So here’s what I want to do today:

  • Tell you a real-life scam story with a big plot twist at the end. Please watch it—it will help you better understand and detect scams.
  • Share five scam prevention tools you can begin using today.

Let’s jump in!

This scam attempt hit too close to home

Note: This video was originally produced for our monthly client newsletter, Guidepost.

—Conversation Transcript—

 

Hi everyone, I’m Doug Denlinger, a partner here at LifeGuide. And I am cranked up. Today, I want to start with a story about a man I know named Jim. Please listen closely because what happened to Jim will most likely happen to you or someone you care about. Okay, listen up.

Just a few months ago, on a beautiful spring day, Jim was finishing up outside from an afternoon spent mowing his lawn and making it look pristine—a small pleasure he took great pride in. Tired yet satisfied from a job well done, Jim came inside, poured himself a tall, cold glass of iced tea, and sat down at his computer to check his email.
What he didn’t realize then was that his afternoon was about to take a hard left turn.

As Jim opened his inbox, a pop-up appeared, warning him of a possible security breach. The message said that his computer might have been hacked and that he needed to call a tech support number immediately. It also warned him not to shut down his computer under any circumstances. Jim was really concerned yet relieved that his antivirus software was on the job, so Jim called tech support.

On the other end of the line, a woman answered. “Microsoft Tech support, my name is Susan, how may I help you today?” Susan was kind and spoke with a calm and reassuring tone, making Jim feel at ease. Susan explained that she would need to verify some of Jim’s information to proceed: his name, date of birth, and address. Feeling it was standard procedure, Jim provided the details without a second thought. Susan then informed him that, in order to run a few diagnostics and figure out exactly what was going on, she would need to remotely access his computer. She instructed him to click the link in the pop-up window, which he did.

Jim watched as Susan took control of his screen, her mouse cursor moving rapidly as she “checked” his system. A minute or two passed, and when Susan came back on the line, there was a noticeable change in her tone. It was no longer calm and reassuring; now, it was filled with urgency and concern. She told Jim that she had found something very troubling. She claimed there were several files on his computer that contained child pornography. Naturally, Jim was horrified. How could this even be possible? This was so far outside of anything he could have ever imagined being on his computer.

Susan said that whether he knew it or not, possessing such material was a federal offense—something that could lead to steep fines, jail time, and a lifetime on state and federal offender lists. But that wasn’t all. She also found evidence that his financial information might have been compromised, making Jim a potential victim of a widespread bank fraud.

By this point, Jim was rattled. His head was spinning, and he could hardly believe what he was hearing. When Susan asked which bank he used, the first bit of doubt entered his head. He had heard over and over to not give out sensitive information over the phone. Sensing Jim’s hesitation, Susan assured him that he didn’t need to say it out loud, and that she would just list several banks involved in the fraud and Jim could simply confirm. Jim agreed, and Susan began listing off banks.

PNC…no…
Wells Fargo…no…
Susquehanna FCU…nope…
Member’s First…
Jim paused.

Susan asked if this was his bank, and Jim’s heart sank as he confirmed it was.

Susan told Jim that the situation was serious but assured him that he was in good hands. She explained how she was going to transfer him to another person from the bank’s investigation department. Susan put him on a brief hold before coming back on the line and introducing Mark.

Mark explained that his job was to help Jim protect his money. He shared that, unfortunately, many people had lost access to their accounts because of this fraud with his bank, and the best course of action was for Jim to withdraw all his funds immediately. Mark recommended that Jim go to his local branch and withdraw the money in cash, which they would then move to a new, secure account.

He stressed that Jim should not tell the bank tellers why he was withdrawing the money, as this could compromise the ongoing investigation and they may not let him take out his money.

Jim, now fighting a rising sense of panic, reluctantly agreed. He told Mark that the bank was only a five-minute drive away, and Mark offered to stay on the line while Jim made the trip. As Jim hopped in his truck to head out, a nagging feeling of doubt began to creep in. Something about the whole situation felt off, but he couldn’t quite put his finger on it. Still, anxious to secure his hard-earned savings, he continued to the bank.

When Jim arrived at the bank and asked the teller to withdraw a large sum from his savings account, the teller, naturally, asked why. Remembering Mark’s instructions, Jim simply said that he needed the money to help a friend. However, the teller looked concerned and went to get the branch manager. When the manager arrived, he began asking Jim more detailed questions. Feeling increasingly uneasy, Jim dropped his phone into his pocket and explained the situation to the bank manager. The manager listened carefully and then told Jim, with a firm but sympathetic tone, that he was being scammed. When Jim pulled his phone out of his pocket, Mark had already hung up.

In that moment, the reality of the situation hit Jim like a ton of bricks. He had almost been duped into handing over a large chunk of his savings to a con artist. The relief was overwhelming, but so was his embarrassment. How could he have been so close to falling for something like this?

And here’s the part that really hits home for me… Jim isn’t just any guy. He’s not some naive person who doesn’t know better. Jim is actually James Lamar Denlinger — my dad! Yes, my dad—one of the smartest, most intentional guys I know. A man who prides himself on being careful and well-informed. If this can happen to him, it can happen to anyone.
Now, luckily, my dad didn’t lose any money that day. But the embarrassment and hassle factor was high. He also spent hours cleaning up the damage—wiping his computer of the spyware they had installed, closing his current bank accounts and opening new ones (for real this time), freezing his credit, changing all of his direct deposits for his pension and social security, and on and on.

And here’s the thing: My dad is one of the lucky ones! Thank God he sensed something was off and the bank teller was trained to recognize the signs of a scam. Not everyone catches it before it’s too late. There are countless stories, and I can think of five people I know right off the top of my head, people who have lost thousands… some tens of thousands, and ones comes to mind who lost more than $100,000. They are people who, like my dad, are smart and cautious and were still able to be caught in the web of a well-crafted scam. And once the money is gone, it’s gone. In most cases there is no insurance and almost no way to get that money back.

Now, I share all of this with you today because I want you to understand—I need you to understand—if it can happen to Jim, my dad, it can happen to you. It can happen to your loved ones. It can happen to anyone. That’s why it’s crucial to stay vigilant and informed. Scammers are becoming more sophisticated every day, preying on even the savviest among us. These criminals know exactly how to manipulate your trust, and they are getting better at it all the time. And I am sick of it!

So please, please, please — read the tips in this month’s email and share this story with those you care about. We need to talk about this. These scammers count on people being isolated, scared and embarrassed. The best defense against these criminals is knowledge, awareness, and caution. And the bottom line is: never send any money (via wires, cash, gift cards) to anyone that you don’t know. Just hang up, turn off your computer, and call someone you trust. Being a target of a scam is NOT your fault, and it is nothing to be embarrassed about – it is just like your house getting robbed.

To be clear—if you ever find yourself in a situation that doesn’t feel right, stop all communications, and CALL US here at LifeGuide. Any of our advisors will help you. I don’t care if you are a client or not. Heck, you can call me directly! I’ll be more than happy to talk with anyone on your behalf. I don’t want to see any more of our clients—or anyone, for that matter—lose another dime to these lowlife predators.

According to Lending Tree, last year Pennsylvanians lost $158 million to fraud and scams—over $150 million of hard-earned savings!

We have got to protect ourselves and the ones we care about. Talk about it with your parents, friends, kids… everyone. Share this email. Let’s put these crooks out of business!

Stay safe from scammers

Use the five tools below to help keep you and your loved ones safe from scammers.

 

1) The Cool-Off Countdown

Scammers thrive off urgency and heightened emotion, putting us in “fight or flight” mode that literally turns off the thinking, logical side of our brains. Before you act, use the Cool-Off Countdown to get your “thinking brain” back online!

Example scenario:

  • A pop-up suddenly appears on your computer screen, warning you that your computer has some type of virus and instructs you to call the support number provided immediately.

How to use:

  • Take some deep breaths and count to ten to give the rational part of your brain time to get back up and running.
  • In the case above, this looks like shutting down your computer immediately and calling your computer guy—not the number listed. (Note: If you don’t have a “computer guy,” you can call Kirbtech at 717-258-3789. They do all our tech and can be trusted. Tell them Doug from LifeGuide referred you, and they may even give you a discount!)

The bottom line: If you find yourself in an emotional, urgent situation, recognize it as a red flag. Take a deep breath, count to ten, and THINK before taking any next steps.

2) The Pause & Probe

Don’t make any rash decisions. Use the Pause & Probe to critically evaluate something that feels too good to be true or too dire of a situation to make sense.

Example scenarios:

  • You get a call or an email saying that you’ve won a big contest or are the beneficiary of a large international estate.
  • You get a call or an email that the IRS is going to take your house or garnish your wages unless you pay your “back taxes, penalties, and interest” immediately.

How to use:

  • First, PAUSE — DO NOT respond or engage right away.
  • Then, PROBE — Get critical and ask yourself the obvious questions.
    • “How could I win a contest I didn’t even enter?”
    • “How could I inherit a massive estate from someone I didn’t even know?”
    • “I know I’ve been paying my taxes, and this is the first I’ve heard from the IRS…why is this suddenly so urgent?”

The bottom line:  If something seems too good to be true or too dire to make sense, it most likely is.

3) The Polite Power Play

When something feels a bit off, but you don’t want to be rude, use the Polite Power Play to kindly yet firmly end communication.

Example scenario:

  • You get an unsolicited call explaining that your bank account may have been compromised and, to get things fixed, you’ll first need to verify your identity—your name, address, date of birth, account number, and social security number.

How to use:

  • Kindly yet firmly say, “I appreciate you bringing this issue to my attention. I never provide my personal information over the phone, as I’m sure you can understand! I will talk with my local representative and take care of it. Thank you very much and have a nice day!” and then HANG UP.

The bottom line: Never give out personal information to an unsolicited contact. Instead, find your bank’s actual phone number online and call them directly, or visit a branch office.

4) The Trustworthy Transaction

When someone requests payments via wire transfer, Western Union, crypto, prepaid debit or gift cards, remember the Trustworthy Transaction and treat these as major red flags.

Example scenario:

  • You come across a big-ticket item on Facebook Marketplace that you have been searching for for months, and it’s a great deal! When you contact the seller, they confirm it’s still available, but several people are also interested. They say that, if you want it, you need to wire a down payment on it right away.

How to use:

  • End all communication and report the seller.
  • Never pay via wire transfer, crypto, or prepaid cards of any kind.
  • Only buy items online from reputable, well-known websites.
  • If purchasing from a site like Facebook Marketplace or Craigslist, only buy in-person in a safe, public space. Never pay for holds or to have an item shipped.

The bottom line: Only buy from people you trust. Anyone asking for payment via wire transfer, Western Union, crypto, or prepaid debit or gift cards is almost certainly a scammer.

5) The Phone-a-Friend

Scammers rely on isolating you through urgency, shame and embarrassment, conspiracy theories, and even perceived romantic connections. Don’t take the bait. Instead, Phone-a-Friend to gain some trusted, objective insight.

Example scenario:

  • You’re a middle-aged man, and a much younger, extremely beautiful woman comes out of nowhere, usually while you are online, and begins to take a not-so-subtle interest in you.

How to use:

  • Before you act, call someone you trust. Explain the situation and ask for their honest input. Don’t let fear or embarrassment (which scammers rely on!) keep you from making an important call.

The bottom line: Call someone you trust to help you navigate any situation that feels off.

Five tools to stay safe from scammers

My commitment to you!

If you feel that any interaction is off in any way, please call us! As LifeGuide’s Managing partner, I personally commit to you that we will talk to anyone—client or not!—100% confidential and free of charge. I don’t want to see anyone lose a dime to these crooks!

—Doug Denlinger, RLP®, CKA®

Contact Us ▸

My commitment to you!

If you feel that any interaction is off in any way, please call us! As LifeGuide’s Managing partner, I personally commit to you that we will talk to anyone—client or not!—100% confidential and free of charge. I don’t want to see anyone lose a dime to these crooks!

—Doug Denlinger, RLP®, CKA®

Contact Us ▸